Pepper Jack Mac and Cheese: Zesty Creamy Pasta

This Pepper Jack mac and cheese is incredibly delicious — rich, creamy, and just the right amount of zesty heat. It’s comfort food with a spicy twist, perfect for anyone who enjoys bold flavors in a simple, satisfying dish.

Using beef broth as the cooking liquid elevates the flavor far beyond plain water. The broth adds depth and gives the macaroni a pleasant, slightly caramelized color. If you prefer, chicken broth works well too.

My kids grew up in a home that celebrates a variety of foods, so they’re adventurous eaters. They appreciate bold flavors, and that makes it easy to serve dishes with a little extra spice. If your family prefers milder food, you can substitute Monterey Jack or mild cheddar for the pepper Jack.

While the recipe calls for pepper Jack to deliver that signature kick, you can customize the cheese to taste. Velveeta will create an ultra-smooth texture, though many cooks prefer natural cheeses for their flavor and texture. This version balances tangy sour cream with the buttery richness of real cheese for a luxuriously creamy finish.

What You’ll Need

3-¼ cups beef broth (or chicken broth)

2 cups uncooked macaroni

2 teaspoons paprika (sweet or smoked)

1 teaspoon dried marjoram

1 teaspoon dried oregano

1 cup water

¼ teaspoon salt

¼ teaspoon black pepper

½ teaspoon lemon juice

1-½ cups shredded pepper Jack cheese (see notes for substitutions)

½ cup full-fat sour cream or plain yogurt

2 tablespoons butter

How to Make It

1. In a large Dutch oven or heavy pot, bring the beef (or chicken) broth, water, and uncooked macaroni to a rolling boil over high heat.

2. Stir in the paprika, marjoram, oregano, salt, and black pepper. Reduce the heat to low, cover the pot, and let the macaroni simmer.

3. Simmer for about 20 minutes, stirring once halfway through to prevent sticking. Check the macaroni near the end of the time — it should be al dente, slightly firm but cooked through.

4. Turn off the heat. Add the lemon juice, shredded pepper Jack, sour cream (or yogurt), and butter. Stir until the cheese and butter are fully melted and the sauce is creamy. Serve immediately while hot.

Tips

– Make sure the broth and water reach a full rolling boil before lowering the heat and covering. This ensures a steady simmer to cook the macaroni evenly.

– Watch the pot closely for the first few minutes after adding the lid so it doesn’t boil over. You can wait a minute after reducing the heat before covering to avoid overflow.

– Keep your final ingredients at room temperature while the macaroni cooks. This prevents the cheese and sour cream from cooling the pasta too much and helps everything melt smoothly.

– If you want a milder dish, substitute Monterey Jack or mild cheddar for the pepper Jack. For an extra-smooth texture, try adding a small amount of processed cheese like Velveeta, though natural cheeses will give better flavor complexity.

This Pepper Jack mac and cheese is best enjoyed fresh and hot. It’s a quick, flavorful weeknight meal that doubles as a cozy side dish for gatherings. The recipe scales well for larger crowds and reheats nicely — just add a splash of milk when warming to keep the sauce creamy.

📋 Recipe

Don’t Forget to Save This Recipe for Later!